‹ Back to Blog

Is This AI Slop?

Two days of directing Junquer's main menu

junquerdesigndev-logai

Junquer's main menu: an amber terminal on a boom arm in a dim, worn spaceship cabin, with three bar lamps overhead and a brown, polluted Earth through the windows, space elevator cables rising from it

This is the main menu for Junquer, the autobattler I’m working on. You’re on a salvage ship in low Earth orbit. The Earth below is a junkyard, and you use the console in front of you to build your base and take over claims to increase your income.

I didn’t write the code behind it. Claude did, using Opus 5.5 for the cockpit, including the Blender scripts that build and render the interior of the ship. I didn’t model, paint or render anything by hand either. What I did was direct it. This menu is the product of about two full days of dedicated work, in dozens of short messages. Most of those messages were some version of “no”, “less” or “not there”.

There’s a lot of anger at AI art right now. I understand a good part of it. A lot of what gets called slop is one prompt, one image, posted (incidentally, that overlaps with what a lot of people consider to be vibe code slop). So I want to show what went into this, step by step, and then ask an honest question. Is this still the thing people are against?

What’s in the art

Before the story, here’s what the menu is made of, because “AI art” can cover many things.

There’s no image generator anywhere in it. The ship’s window wall, the console housing and the boom arm are 3D models that Opus wrote as Python scripts for Blender, about 3,500 lines of code. Blender renders those to images. The Earth is a live 3D scene in the browser, built from NASA’s public domain Blue Marble and Black Marble maps, which a script works over to make the planet brown and smoggy. The station halfway up the elevator tether and the ship you see in orbit are two models by re1monsen on Sketchfab, under CC BY 4.0. The engine hum is a recording from Pixabay. The flickering lamp and the distant clangs in the hull are synthesized in the browser.

So the machine wrote code, and the code made the pictures. The decisions about what the pictures should say were mine. And that is what I’m curious about. Does that difference matter to you?

Where it started

The menu has been a ship’s terminal since I started the prototype back in August. I told Opus to build a menu interface that looks like it belongs on a salvager’s ship in space, orbiting Earth, managing everything in the game. I had established the overall color scheme while working on the prototype gameplay. I wanted it to feel sort of scrappy.

Its first answer was a deck plan of the ship, with rooms for each mode. It definitely missed the mark, so I told it I wanted “a command terminal, like a captain might use”, with a frame like a touch screen someone actually puts their hands on.

The August version: an amber terminal in a bolted bezel, floating on a black page

That’s the conn. One amber screen, a terminal prompt, and every command is also a button and an F-key. The stamped plate at the bottom (“PATT. 7 CONN CONSOLE · WIPE GLASS DAILY”) and the PWR, LINK and FAULT lamps were detail touches it added on its own, and I kind of like them. I ended up making the link light functional. This was good enough for a prototype, but it floated in nothing. It didn’t feel like a place.

The one-shot

On October 20 I sat down to refine that initial impression. I wanted the player to feel like they’re sitting in a ship when they open the game. So I started up a new Opus session and sent the following prompt:

update the main menu so it looks like a cockpit in a spaceship, with a viewport showing part of the earth in the bottom right. the menu console is then like the pilot’s control console

Sixteen minutes later I had this.

The first cockpit attempt: the same terminal over flat drawn panels, with a bright blue Earth in a window at the bottom right

It did what I asked. There’s a cockpit, there’s a viewport, there’s the Earth in the bottom right. The viewport itself looks a bit janky, but it could have been massaged into a more meaningful shape. I could have done just a bit more and shipped it, and that’s the version I think people picture when they hear “made with AI”.

It also looked like a web page pretending to be a ship. The frame was flat panels and one strut. The Earth was a bright blue marble, which doesn’t fit at all with the game’s story. Nothing said anyone had ever flown this thing.

I wanted something that looked much more professional, designed, real. So I followed up with my second prompt:

the earth and stars look good. but the viewport looks terrible. make it look professional, and like an actual ship. and make the control panel have a boom arm going off the bottom left, like it is attached to something.

I also sent some stock images of spaceship cockpits and window views, like this photo of the space station’s Cupola. I specifically told the agent not to copy the images, but to use them as references for the look and feel of being in space.

NASA astronaut Tracy Caldwell Dyson looking out through the Cupola windows of the International Space Station, with a blue and white Earth below

What it got from them was weight. Heavy window frames, the curve of the planet, a room you sit in. The finished menu doesn’t look like any of them, but it does have a similar feel in the window frame.

The useful part of my message was specifying what worked, and what didn’t. The Earth and stars were safe. Everything else had to go.

A real ship

That’s when the method changed. The wall stopped being drawn in the browser and became a Blender model: three panes in heavy, stepped, bolted frames, a header beam, a sill, conduit and vents. The console got its boom arm.

The rendered window wall: heavy framed panes, a header beam and sill, with the console hanging off a boom arm on the left

Now the wall looked better than the console, so I asked Opus to bring the console “up to par with the visual quality of the blender rendered cockpit”, and it got its own render with the same camera and the same light.

The window tells the story

Junquer is set on a junkyard Earth. A calm blue planet out the window immediately gives the wrong feel. So:

make the view out the viewport dynamic. rotating earth, twinkling stars. maybe some other ships in the distance, maybe space elevators bringing goods up from the surface. and make earth less blue and serene. this is a future where earth is polluted and trashed

The live view: a brown, smog-hazed Earth with city lights on its night side and space elevator cables rising out of it

The first version had a lot of traffic in orbit. I cut it down to one occasional blocky freighter and the stations on the elevator cables.

Things it got wrong first

Some first tries were plain mistakes. To give a real sense of depth, Opus made the console drift a little with the mouse. It felt very bad, so I told it to keep the console still, and to use shadow and contrast for depth instead.

Most of the mistakes were about amount. I asked for the frame to look used:

add some nicks and scratches to he frame, this ship should look used

The first pass looked like the ship had been in a fight. Eight minutes later: “too much scratching and chipping on the frame.” That back and forth repeated all through the two days. Every first pass at wear overshot, and every time a quick “tone it down” prompt pulled it back.

Three versions of the console housing's corner: bare, the pass that went too far, and the final few flecks of bare steel on each fold

I don’t think that’s a flaw in the tool so much as the actual job. Someone has to look at it and say when it’s right. I did that dozens of times.

People were here

On the second day I changed how I gave directions. Almost every message was a screenshot that I marked up to show where I saw issues.

A screenshot of the menu with a pink circle drawn around the foot of the window post

And I stopped describing effects (“add wear”) and started describing people. This ship isn’t new. Someone has lived on it.

add the initials C + L in a heart to this spot, as if someone scratched it into the metal

That took five messages. The one-shot looked too clean, too perfect. So I told it to “give the heart a stray small scratch or two around the sharpest bends, as if the artist struggled to make that curve.” That told Opus where the stray lines go and why they’re there. It still took quite a lot of iteration to get to something I was happy with: tilting the initials, pulling the heart lower, making the scratches deeper…

Close up of a heart scratched into the metal at the foot of the window post, with C + L inside it, cut around a bolt head

I wanted to add this “lived in” story throughout the scene. The window sill got worn dull along the bottom, “as if people have spent time sitting there and worn the paint down a bit staring out the window”. The post between the panes got rubbed pale at hand height. Then:

tone it down a bit. but make that bolt head look like it got polished by constant touch. like bronze statues where you can tell where people’s hands have been

The window post three ways: before, with heavy hand wear, and the final version with fainter wear and one bolt polished bright

And next to the window, a small open steel box with a rag in it, one corner hanging out. It’s the rag the crew uses to keep the glass clean so everyone can see out. I would imagine if I lived on a ship, that view would matter a lot. Incidentally, one might notice that there is some grime in the corners of the console, but none on the window. That window view is very important.

The box got knocked about too, then less, because the first version had “giant corner bends”.

A worn steel box on the sill with one corner of a cloth rag hanging over its front edge

None of these details are things a player needs. You’ll probably never notice the lack of grime on the window, or the half-degree tilt of the console. But together they’re the story I wanted the menu to tell. You’re not the first person in this seat. People sat at this window, held on to that post, carved their initials into it, and kept the glass clean for each other.

Sound, and leaving

The ship needed to sound like a ship too. I asked for the old submarine-style ambience back, then a sound for the flickering lamp (“make it more like flickering neon sign”, then “too loud. tone it down a lot”), then “the occasional distant metal on metal clang that would reverberate through the hull”.

When you pick a game, the LINK lamp blinks green, uplink lines type out on the console, and the view pushes into the glass until the screen fills the window. The game’s loading screen picks up on that same dark frame. That console is where the player controls the action, even if they don’t see it. Leaving a game runs the same trip backwards. My first note on it was that it ran too fast to read. It’s also where some of the load time hides, so it can afford to take its time.

The menu, then uplink lines printing on the console, then the view pushed into the glass as the menu fades

What I actually did

Reading back through my messages, I noticed a few habits that seemed to do most of the work:

  • Give the cause, not the effect. “As if many hands have held onto the beam there” says where the wear goes, how big it is and why. “Add wear” misses the nuance, and that extra context helps the model produce something closer to what you want.
  • A picture is worth a thousand words. Providing a screenshot with problem areas circled was much more valuable than trying to describe things with just words.
  • Correct by amount. “Too much”, “tone it down a lot” and “i don’t see it” were usually enough. Not every prompt had to be long and detailed.
  • Tell the model what’s working. “The earth and stars look good” kept the good half alive while the rest got thrown out.

None of that is drawing. But it is deciding what the thing is about and noticing when it’s off, over and over, until it isn’t. That’s the part I’d call mine. It is my brainchild, even though I didn’t draw or model any of it. It felt like using a tool in Photoshop that an artist might use to add a specific texture somewhere, but much more powerful.

So, is it slop?

I honestly don’t know how people will see this. My guess is that a lot of the backlash is aimed at the one-shot, the version I got in sixteen minutes. What took two days was everything after it.

I also know effort doesn’t settle it for everyone. Some people object to how these models were trained, to the resources they use, or to what this means for people who make art for a living, and how hard I worked doesn’t answer either of those. I’m not going to pretend it does.

And it isn’t finished. I can still see things I want to change. I’m sure someone with real training in art and design can point out a thousand things I missed. But I’d like to hear from you. Does knowing how it was made change how you see it? Does it matter that there’s no image generator in it, or is “AI wrote the code” the same thing to you? Come tell me on Discord. I’d especially like to hear from people who think it’s still slop.

Under the windows: the Earth's night side with city lights, an elevator cable with its station, and the carved heart on the post's foot

Credits

  • Earth maps: NASA Visible Earth. Blue Marble Next Generation by Reto Stöckli, NASA Earth Observatory. Blue Marble clouds, NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. Black Marble 2016 by Joshua Stevens and Miguel Román, NASA Earth Observatory. Recolored for the game.
  • Space Station 4 and Space Station Modules by re1monsen, CC BY 4.0. Reduced, re-textured and re-lit for the game.
  • Cupola photo: ISS024-E-014263, NASA, public domain.
  • Engine hum: Spaceship Ambient by freesound_community on Pixabay.

Comments

Loading comments...